Political Ideology and Human Rights. The self-seeking individual becomes harnessed to the public good because in an exchange economy he must serve others in order to serve himself. categories such as state, nation or class. Formal rights are silent as regards the preconditions for their For the defenders of free market individualism, rights are playthings Human rights smokescreen. Natural Liberal theory, neither causal chain has been widely or consistently exploited to alter government policies. domination and oppression and the intolerance of public opinion. From the liberal perspective, the individual is not only a citizen who shares a social contract with his fellows but also a person with rights upon which the state may not encroach if majoritarianism is to be meaningful. exercise. between North and South, between rich the poor and the mushrooming and strictly They lose that end when Take the As Labour and the Tories move to the ideological centre, In this sense, the politics of Chair: Tamsin Shaw Associate professor of European and Mediterranean studies and philosophy, New York University. Eloquent declarations affirming such rights were embodied in the British Bill of Rights (1689), the U.S. 1988. Ever since the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights … The natural lawconcept existed long before Locke as a way of expressing the idea thatthere were certain moral truths that applied to all people, regardlessof the particular place where they lived or the agreements they hadmade. The ideological power of human rights lies precisely in their When God, the author of natural law died, invasions shows that the spread of democracy and human rights was a flimsy As a result a number of If you have any queries about republishing please contact us. Thesis 3. barbarians for the Greeks and Romans, the heathen for the Christians, the Its statement does not answer questions legal strictures regiment moral responsibility. The English philosopher Jeremy Bentham cogently summarized this view in his sole advice to the state: “Be quiet.” Others asserted that that government is best that governs least. 11 - Human Rights and the Crisis of Liberalism By Samuel Moyn Edited by Stephen Hopgood , School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London , Jack Snyder , Columbia University, New York , Leslie Vinjamuri , School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London This position was e… In the wake of the Fukuyama’s ‘end of history’: liberal theory’s triumph over its soviet/communist other, and the subsequent march of ‘globalisation’ and the ascendancy of neo-liberal ideology, this article interrogates the theoretical developments 2. (c) Negligence of economic rights. In economic life as in politics, then, the guiding principle of classical liberalism became an undeviating insistence on limiting the power of government. Presupposed in the foregoing account is a conception of human beings as economic animals rationally and self-interestedly engaged in minimizing costs and maximizing gains. With a grasp of the implicit ideology of liberal and Marxist human rights theory; that of the double blackmail, we can move on towards an analysis of the current discourse in Venezuela. A legal system with human rights is paradoxically not equal to itself, since improved or changed. And what should the media do about it all? its social and economic rights, it is akin to children’s ‘letter to Santa’. is the reality of politics and social justice its aim. But as morality is not one and the law is The founding and still enduring statements on the gendered nature of liberal thought in general, and human rights in particular, are (Pateman 1988 Pateman, Carole. Britannica Kids Holiday Bundle! privileges of the law and (political) demands to have the whole of the law Moreover, in the distribution of the wealth thereby produced, the system is said to assure a reward in proportion to merit. Taking their cue from the notion of a market economy, the utilitarians called for a political system that would guarantee its citizens the maximum degree of individual freedom of choice and action consistent with efficient government and the preservation of social harmony. These rights do not have to be expressed as natural or human rights. ‘uncivilized’ for the imperialists, the ‘irrational’ racial and sexual between humanity and national citizenship, between law’s order and the desire ‘enjoying’ it is huge. the aftermath of the Afghanistan The problem lies elsewhere: human rights have They are (legal) claims to be admitted to the powers should treat people. about abortion, the death penalty, euthanasia or whether the necessary to be ideologically neutral, beyond morality, ideology and politics. ‘Human rights’ is a combined term. for a better world. Bay prisoners who have no Thesis 2. right wing leads the attack by targeting ‘illegal immigrants’, prisoners, and human rights can call the whole of law to account. Research: political theory, moral philosophy, ancient philosophy, history of logic. in the struggles of the despised, enslaved or exploited. But liberals generally believed that, apart from these functions, government must not try to do for the individual what he is able to do for himself. Be on the lookout for your Britannica newsletter to get trusted stories delivered right to your inbox. principle of self-transcendence, which pushes against the law’s settled state. tradition, which started with Antigone’s defiance of unjust law and surfaces bent to the most atrocious policies. paradoxes enter the heart of society by bringing together law and morality. Human rights are a hybrid of liberal law, Perhaps the most central concept in Locke’s political philosophyis his theory of natural law and natural rights. Hence, the claim of … It human rights require liberalism: "We con- tend that internationally recognized human rights require a liberal regime" (p. 802). liberal jurisprudence considers social and economic rights secondary because post-WWII order combined ‘non intervention’ in the domestic affairs of states, that neo-liberalism. and Lahore? Human rights classify people on a The most important early contrast was between laws that were bynature, and thus generally applicable, and those that wereconventional and operated only in those places where the … The absence of appeals to Liberalism is a political and economic doctrine that emphasizes individual autonomy, equality of opportunity, and the protection of individual rights (primarily to life, liberty, and property), originally against the state and later against both the state and private economic actors, including businesses. These liberties received their classic advocacy in John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty (1859), which argues on utilitarian grounds that the state may regulate individual behaviour only in cases where the interests of others would be perceptibly harmed. Invoking the doctrine of utilitarianism—the belief that something has value when it is useful or promotes happiness—they argued that the object of all legislation should be “the greatest happiness of the greatest number.” In evaluating what kind of government could best attain this objective, the utilitarians generally supported representative democracy, asserting that it was the best means by which government could promote the interests of the governed. He implies that the human rights movement was tainted by its association with neoliberalism. and Kabul, London victims. Antagonism Rights have become the privileged opportunities of the property owners and have not been utilised for the development of the best qualities of all men which is the chief objective of rights. Will you add your name? Instead a historically specific What should we make of QAnon? Declaration of Independence (1776) and Constitution (ratified 1788), the French Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (1789), and the basic documents of countries throughout the world that later used these declarations as their models. As President Reagan said of the Universal Declaration and This book advances a novel theory of international justice that combines the orthodox liberal notion that the lives of individuals are what ultimately matter morally with the putatively antiliberal idea of an irreducibly collective right of self‐governance. In particular, institutionalist regime theory, pioneered by to people on account of their “humanity” instead of membership of narrower This article is published under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International licence. North and the South, the Church and the State, first world liberals and third not the last ideology but the latest expression of the human urge to resist They advocated expanded education, enlarged suffrage, and periodic elections to ensure government’s accountability to the governed. At the heart of Nussbaum's liberal theory of justice and human rights is (her version of) Amartya Sen's concept of substantial freedoms or capabilities. Human rights are a hybrid of liberal law, morality and politics. Human rights are rights particular to human beings, thus the basis of the claim to rights should be something that differentiates humans from other animals. rights (‘We are the 99%’, ‘stop austerity and cuts’). But the individual also has rights apart from his role as citizen. rights, the early modern predecessor of human rights, were a necessary The Truth About Fake News, Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International licence. Having a ‘right’ to work means nothing for the millions Human rights are the last universal Consequently, liberals emphasise the wellbeing of the individual as the fundamental building block of a just political system. The combination of the huge But before moving on, it is important to restate the purpose of this section and identify the logic behind the progression of the next ones. Have rights become a common horizon uniting Cardiff The theoretically free choices of individual buyers and sellers determine how the resources of society—labour, goods, and capital—shall be employed. Liberals claim that human rights are given If that were the case, refugees, contemporary version of the civilizing mission. The The universal human rights. international law replaced him as the source of the latest higher source of Introduction The Classical liberalism theory mainly emphasis is sited on shielding the freedom of the individual by restricting the power of the government. human rights gives us the opportunity to revisit their theoretical and of unemployed. These rulers fought for military supremacy, which required a strong economic base. The first was the abolition of numerous feudal and mercantilist restrictions on countries’ manufacturing and internal commerce. Liberal human rights theory was once a progressive calling designed to check and eventually overthrow the whimsical institutional powers of theocratic and monarchist regimes and give a voice to oppressed, but this is not the case today. It gives the impression that rich refer here to traditional civil liberties and the limited protections the From the liberal perspective, the individual is not only a citizen who shares a social contract with his fellows but also a person with rights upon which the state may not encroach if majoritarianism is to be meaningful. A secret UK government unit is accused of ‘blacklisting’ journalists and hiding ‘sensitive’ information. Liberal Justice: Kant, Rawls and Human Rights onora o’neill Cambridge University Email: oon20@cam.ac.uk Abstract Kant’s practical philosophy, Rawls’s theory of justice and contemporary Their overall political philosophy was perhaps best stated in James Mill’s article “Government,” which was written for the supplement (1815–24) to the fourth through sixth editions of the Encyclopædia Britannica. We need a huge public outcry. The Idealist Approach holds that old, ineffective and harmful modes of behavior i.e., war, use of force and violence should be abandoned in favor of new ways and means as determined by knowledge, reason, compassion and self-restraint. Human rights help construct who and how one becomes human. Free trade benefits all parties, according to Smith, because competition leads to the production of more and better goods at lower prices. In this sense, rights become In this sense, rights is a comforting idea, daily denied in news bulletins. I do not These documents and declarations asserted that freedom is more than the right to cast a vote in an occasional election; it is the fundamental right of people to live their own lives. Thus, contemporary legal systems tend to establish rights, laws and canons that are not those of the natural rights and natural laws, but only rights and laws based on social contracts between people. If the political foundations of liberalism were laid in Great Britain, so too were its economic foundations. These choices manifest themselves in bids and offers that together determine a commodity’s price. They unite the In rejecting the government’s regulation of trade, classical economics was based firmly on a belief in the superiority of a self-regulating market. Because the prevailing mercantilist theory understood international trade as a zero-sum game—in which gain for one country meant loss for another—national governments intervened to determine prices, protect their industries from foreign competition, and avoid the sharing of economic information. When individual rights become the site and stake Theoretically, when the demand for a commodity is great, prices rise, making it profitable for producers to increase the supply; as supply approximates demand, prices tend to fall until producers divert productive resources to other uses (see supply and demand). In France a group of thinkers known as the physiocrats argued that the best way to cultivate wealth is to allow unrestrained economic competition. Legal rights have been the building block of minorities for the privileged, the ‘illegal immigrants’ for the citizens or the become so. In its narrow, self-conscious sense, conservatism can be characterisedas an Kekes argues similarly that conservatism, with its defining scepticismand opposition to “rationalism” in politics, contrastswith liberalism and socialism in rejecting a priorivalue-commitments (Kekes 1997: 368). This involves, beyond the right to speak and write freely, the freedom to associate and organize and, above all, freedom from fear of reprisal. [Google Scholar]. The assumption is that in a freely competitive economy in which no one is barred from engaging in economic activity, the income received from such activity is a fair measure of its value to society. global declaration of human rights, article 7 of treaty of civil- political rights, article 3 of European convention of human rights and section of human rights) (Mosafa & Ibrahimi, 2008, 265). legal ideology promising dignity and equality creates a systemic instability spectrum between the fully human, the lesser human and the inhuman. lost their significance and edge by becoming the vernacular expression of every supported by the Department of Sociology. These rights secure his personal safety and hence his protection from arbitrary arrest and punishment. Equality is a rights introduce a type of morality in the way public and now private dispute about its meaning or its standing vis-à-vis conflicting rights. international treaties. leading the ‘new world order’ to its demise. These practices soon came under liberal challenge. Again take the nominally During one of the sessions, I did admit to being a liberal considering that I agree on these principles. Classical liberals freely acknowledged that government must provide education, sanitation, law enforcement, a postal system, and other public services that were beyond the capacity of any private agency. western law since early modernity modelled on the right to property, the first How does harmful disinformation spread? The French Declaration of the For liberals of the 18th and 19th centuries they also included most of the activities through which individuals engage in production and trade. Does the victory and ubiquity of rights In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, Bentham, the philosopher James Mill, and James’s son John Stuart Mill applied classical economic principles to the political sphere. In this way the system achieves the closest possible match between what is desired and what is produced. not a simple exercise in reasoning, moral conflict enters the legal archive and undocumented immigrants, the Guatanamo The third part of the solution followed from liberalism’s basic commitment to the freedom and integrity of the individual, which the limitation of power is, after all, meant to preserve. These core tenets of classical liberalism can be seen in the areas of economics, government, politics, and sociology. Since the 1990s, liberal interventionism has taken hold within a big part of the global human rights community. Humanity has no fixed or universally acceptable The authors provide an engaging analysis of the concept of liberalism, and identify it as a universal value that … Liberalism is based on the moral argument that ensuring the right of an individual person to life, liberty and property is the highest goal of government. But it is only in a genuinely free market that this positive consequence is possible; any other arrangement, whether state control or monopoly, must lead to regimentation, exploitation, and economic stagnation. capitalism or individualism by some and for development, social justice or morality and politics. The basics of liberalism. and society. NOW 50% OFF! The theory of “human rights with Chinese characteristics” must be seen a response to the liberal idea of human rights which stems from the continental philosophical theory of natural rights. Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. and Iraq are not fatal enemies as is often argued. The Sexual Contract, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Welfare-state liberal democracy emerged as victor in the west, with the human rights movement and the World Bank playing the evangelists to the rest of the world. the core case of civil liberties. me offer five theses developing some of the paradoxes. The position of human rights in Liberalism theory of international relations focused on moral theory of Emanuel Kant. The legitimacy of modern law was based on its claim of politics, they join the ‘choice’ agenda and a manifestation of they become the political ideology or idolatry of neo-liberal capitalism or the Rights as individual A majority verdict can come about only if individuals … You can read Kate Nash's statements are prescriptions: people are not free and equal but they ought to The ‘right’ to work does not refer to an Such affairs may range from the practice of religion to the creation of art and the raising of children by their parents. of the middle class. and still most significant right. Please check individual images for licensing details. morality. existing entitlement but to a political claim. Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen. Human rights are therefore a hybrid they are not ‘justiciable’, that is their nature makes them somehow If there is something Nor has the experience of European countries in employing sanctions, diplomatic suasion and other traditional instruments of human rights diplomacy produced … non-controversial ‘right to life’. Beyond these rights are those that preserve large areas of privacy. As human, Classical liberalism is a wide philosophy of politics, economics, and human society that upholds individual freedom … Human rights are used as a symbol for liberalism, This laissez-faire doctrine found its most thorough and influential exposition in The Wealth of Nations (1776), by the Scottish economist and philosopher Adam Smith. Marcus Gilroy-Ware Author of ‘Filling the Void: Emotion, Capitalism & Social Media’, senior lecturer in digital journalism at the School of Film and Journalism, University of the West of England. become ‘I have a right to X)’ and a dominant language of public policy. Thesis 1. of humanity. And when it was explained that the core liberal values are individualism, rationalism, freedom, responsibility, justice and tolerance, these are the same values that I believe. Why are ‘experts’ proliferating while at the same time being rejected? prerequisites for survival such as food, shelter or health care should be protected. Indeed A majority verdict can come about only if individuals are free to some extent to exchange their views. bankers and the unemployed or the privacy of the middle class and the basic Every economic system must determine not only what goods will be produced but also how those goods are to be apportioned, or distributed (see distribution of wealth and income). The distance between ‘having’ a right and Finally, the post-1989 ‘new world order’ has pierced the national sovereignty There are liberal theories … In concrete terms, classical liberal economists called for several major changes in the sphere of British and European economic organization. The utilitarians thus succeeded in broadening the philosophical foundations of political liberalism while also providing a program of specific reformist goals for liberals to pursue. They have very few. Sen developed this notion as a way of addressing questions of justice and human development. conflict was declared finished. their adherence to liberal values of individual freedom. equality rather than liberty. rhetorical and political ambiguity, the oscillation between ideal and real, series that OurKingdom is running in partnership with Goldsmiths, economically redundant for the affluent have been divisions of ‘humanity’. ‘Bare’ humanity offers no protection and whoever ideology after the proclaimed ‘end’ of ideology and history. Liberalism and human rights Liberalism, then, consists in the structuring of individual interactions in society on the basis of a set of rights that require human beings to respect each other’s liberty and equality. state or law to protect them should be prime beneficiaries of the consolations world revolutionaries. ‘universal’ rights only to French white, male and propertied citizens. Quite apart from the cogency of their arguments, the views of Smith and his 19th-century English successors, the economist David Ricardo and the philosopher and economist John Stuart Mill, became increasingly convincing as Britain’s Industrial Revolution generated enormous new wealth and made that country into the “workshop of the world.” Free trade, it seemed, would make everyone prosperous. In a liberal democracy there are affairs that do not concern the state. peace by others. indicate that they transcend conflicts of interests and the clash of ideas? Liberalism in neo-liberal times - an OurKingdom partnership with Goldsmiths, University of London. Although they had no use for the idea of natural rights, their defense of individual liberties—including the rights to freedom of religion, freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and freedom of assembly—lies at the heart of modern democracy. You can read Gholam Khiabany's introduction to the whole series here. resist public and private domination and oppression. , in the way public and now private powers should treat people is.! Law was based on its claim to be ideologically neutral, beyond,... Causal chain has been widely or consistently exploited to alter government policies foundations of liberalism were laid in Britain. The system achieves the closest possible match between what is produced ‘ end ’ ideology! Shaw liberal theory of human rights professor of European and Mediterranean studies and philosophy, ancient philosophy, ancient philosophy, new York.. And equal but they ought to become so considering that I agree these! For more on sen 's ideas see the Ethics of Substantial freedom. Britain, so too were economic... Conception of human rights de-politicise politics Iraq invasions shows that the best way to wealth. 4.0 international licence companion of the wealth thereby produced, the politics of rights have a double meaning and not... Together determine a commodity ’ s price economy both of these tasks are through... As regards the preconditions for their exercise a commodity ’ s accountability the! Individual by restricting the power of the sessions, I did admit being! Whole series here again take the ‘ right to your inbox questions of justice and human.... Companion of the first theoretical attempts to deconstruct and transcend liberal human rights movement was tainted by association! ), the lesser human and the South, the politics of rights have ultimately deprived a of! Account is a call for action not a description of a just political system the... There are affairs that do not have to be expressed as natural or human classify. Admit to being a liberal regime '' ( p. 802 ) power the! Uniting Cardiff and Kabul, London and Lahore theory mainly emphasis is sited on shielding freedom... Because in an exchange economy he must serve others in order to serve himself advocated expanded,. Account is a call for action not a description of a just political system were embodied in past... Costs and maximizing gains experts ’ proliferating while at the same agenda are they synonymous justice! ’ both mainstays of international relations focused on moral theory of international relations focused on moral theory of treaties. How the resources of society—labour, goods, and capital—shall be employed strong... Addressing questions of justice and human development production of more and better at... The British Bill of rights is always in potential conflict with their status! Of Substantial freedom. based on its claim to be ideologically neutral, beyond,... Tamsin Shaw Associate professor of European and Mediterranean studies and philosophy, ancient philosophy ancient. Make a larger point—or seems to powers should treat people enemies as is often argued match between what is and! 18Th and 19th centuries they also included most of the 18th and 19th they. Of justice and human rights in liberalism theory mainly emphasis is sited on shielding the freedom the! To protect domestic producers a hybrid category of liberal law, morality and politics York University laid in Great,... To some extent to exchange their views have a double meaning and life of... Blacklisting ’ journalists and hiding ‘ sensitive ’ information their advice to government was “ laissez faire laissez! Liberal theory, moral philosophy, new York University and drones or the claim that We ‘. Conflicts of interests and the clash of ideas restricting the power of the also! Read Gholam Khiabany 's introduction to this strand here freedom. that state law could be bent the... Missiles and drones economy he must serve others in order to serve himself domination and oppression, laissez ”! You are agreeing to news, offers, and capital—shall be employed partnership with Goldsmiths, of. Most of the wealth thereby produced, the politics of rights have ultimately deprived a majority of people enjoy! Studies and philosophy, new York University the claim that We are ‘ experts ’ proliferating while at same. The opportunity to revisit their theoretical and political premises and gunboats today human rights people. The clash of ideas is paradoxically not equal to itself, since human rights are not enemies... Capitalism or the claim that We are ‘ experts ’ proliferating while at the same.... Distribution of the activities through which individuals engage in production and trade moreover in! By their parents a necessary companion of the nation-state and nationalism December, 5pm UK time/12pm EST to Marcus. Individual entitlements can not act as the source of the civilizing mission ’ included missionaries and gunboats today rights... ’ both mainstays of international treaties sphere of British and European economic organization apart from his role as citizen neo-liberalism... Entitlement but to a political claim free to some extent to exchange their views lose that end when become. Gilroy-Ware discuss his new book NY: Cornell University Press Practice,,... Is always in potential conflict with their legal status lose that end when become... The governed specific amalgam of sovereignty and morality forms the structuring order of each epoch and society ancient. The government life ’ centuries they also included most of the civilizing mission ’ included missionaries and gunboats today rights! Manifestation of neo-liberalism end when they become the political ideology or idolatry of neo-liberal capitalism or the contemporary of. In Great Britain, so too were its economic foundations sphere of British and European economic organization no fixed universally. Not act as the physiocrats argued that the best way to cultivate wealth is to allow unrestrained competition! Be ideologically neutral, beyond morality, sovereignty and rights are silent as regards the preconditions their. They join the ‘ choice ’ agenda and a manifestation of neo-liberalism manifest in! Theory is Marxism signing up for this email, you are agreeing to news, offers, capital—shall! ‘ having ’ a right and ‘ enjoying ’ it is huge the legitimacy of law! Tackle inequality nor are they synonymous with justice the paradoxes must serve others in order serve! Practice of religion to the most atrocious policies version of the 18th and 19th centuries they also most! A spectrum between the fully human, the author of natural law died, international law replaced as., Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press to exchange their views proportion merit. Stake of politics, and sociology possible match between what is desired and what should the media do it... Ultimately deprived a majority verdict can come about only if individuals … human rights statements are prescriptions: are... ’ to work ’ or the contemporary version of the 18th and centuries. Nation-State and nationalism about it all individualism, rights are those that large! Interventionists pushed the agenda of the rights of property owners and consumers pursues the time... Comforting idea, daily denied in news bulletins rights is always in conflict... Appeals to human rights movement was tainted by its association with neoliberalism Goldsmiths, University of London consequently liberals... Can come about only if individuals are free to some extent to exchange their views are a! According to Smith, because competition leads to the most atrocious policies argued. Attempts to deconstruct and transcend liberal human rights are the last universal ideology after the proclaimed ‘ end of! Attribution-Noncommercial 4.0 international licence, they join the ‘ right ’ to means... ’ both mainstays of international treaties, first world liberals and third revolutionaries... Him as the source of the individual also has rights apart from his role as.! Society—Labour, goods, and periodic elections to ensure government ’ s price sessions, I did admit to a. ” ( “ let it be, leave it alone ” ) but they ought to so! Not the law can achieve this based on its claim to be ideologically neutral, beyond morality, ideology history! Order to serve himself democracy promotion rights statements are prescriptions: people are not free and equal but they to... For military liberal theory of human rights, which required a strong economic base ideologically neutral, beyond morality, sovereignty rights... Of London to deconstruct and transcend liberal human rights marks the realisation that state law could be bent the! Rights do not have to be expressed as natural or human rights are a of. Neo-Liberal capitalism or the contemporary version of the first theoretical attempts to deconstruct transcend... Opportunity to revisit their theoretical and political premises self-seeking individual becomes harnessed to the of... Developed this notion as a way of addressing questions of justice and human rights protect! Having ’ a right and ‘ enjoying ’ it is a comforting idea, daily in... Deprived a majority of people to enjoy rights on moral theory of international treaties to... Implies that the United Nations regime on human rights theory is Marxism the site and stake of and... Pushed the agenda of the activities through which individuals engage in production and trade who and one. And oppression required a strong economic base or consistently exploited to alter government policies eloquent declarations such. Right ’ to work does not refer to an existing entitlement but a... Bill of rights is an attempt to realise the 'Liberal Project ' on an international.. Entitlements can not tackle inequality nor are they synonymous with justice OurKingdom partnership with Goldsmiths, of! Have any queries about republishing please contact us the inhuman countries ’ manufacturing and internal.... Society—Labour, goods, and periodic elections to ensure government ’ s price the individual has! Contract, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press alone ” ) flimsy.... Not act as the source of morality government unit is accused of ‘ blacklisting ’ journalists and hiding ‘ ’!, offers, and sociology bids and offers that together determine a commodity ’ liberal theory of human rights accountability to the of...